Why Your Aquarium Plants Keep Dying (and How to Fix Them)
Are your aquarium plants turning yellow, melting, or just not growing the way you hoped? If you’re struggling to keep your plants alive, they might not be getting enough food. Many hobbyists assume that fish waste is enough to feed aquarium plants, but that’s only part of the picture. In reality, plants also get nutrients from natural sources like rock erosion and even lightning strikes, which can’t be easily replicated in a glass box. In this article, we’ll explain the key nutrients your plants need and show you how to properly feed them so you can enjoy a lush, thriving planted aquarium.
Start with the Right Fertilizer for Your Plants
#1 Use an All-in-One Fertilizer for Simplicity
Just like terrestrial plants, aquatic plants need the right mix of nutrients in order to support photosynthesis, grow healthy leaves and roots, and reproduce. These nutrients are typically split into two groups:
- Macronutrients (like nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium) are used in larger amounts and directly fuel plant growth.
- Micronutrients (like iron, manganese, and zinc) are needed in smaller amounts but are still essential for plant health.
If you're new to planted tanks, the easiest place to start is with an all-in-one fertilizer. These products are made to provide a balanced mix of both macronutrients and micronutrients in a single bottle. They’re especially beginner-friendly because you don’t need to measure or mix multiple supplements — just dose according to the instructions.
There are a few types of all-in-one fertilizers to choose from, depending on your tank setup:
- All-in-one fertilizers with nitrogen: Ideal for heavily planted aquariums or tanks with fast-growing plants and few fish, since the fish waste won’t produce enough nitrogen to feed the plants
- All-in-one fertilizers without nitrogen: Great for lightly planted aquariums or those with slower-growing plants and lots of fish, where the fish waste already adds plenty of nitrogen
- Shrimp-safe, all-in-one fertilizers: While most modern fertilizers are safe for fish, shrimp, and snails, some formulas are specifically designed with low copper levels and other adjustments for sensitive invertebrates.
#2 Provide Nutrients in the Ground
Also, think about how your plants absorb nutrients. Most all-in-one fertilizers come in liquid form and work best for plants that prefer consuming nutrients from the water — such as floating plants, stem plants, and rhizome plants (like Anubias and Java fern). On the other hand, heavy root feeders like Amazon swords, Cryptocoryne, and many bulb plants prefer to get their nutrients through their roots, so they need a different type of fertilizer. To meet their needs, use root tabs or specialized aqua soil ensures that these plants receive a steady supply of nutrients directly where they need them most.
If you’re setting up a new tank and would love to grow a beautiful crypt garden or lush carpeting plants, consider starting with a nutrient-rich substrate that provides a natural foundation for plant growth, reducing the need for constant fertilization. For existing tanks with inert substrates like gravel or sand (or if your old aqua soil has become depleted), use planting tweezers to strategically insert root tabs near the plants’ roots, and they’ll slowly release fertilizer into the ground. Just remember to add more root tabs as your plants grow bigger and hungrier, especially if you notice yellowing or melting leaves.
#3 Customize with Macro and Micro Fertilizers
If you find that your plants still aren’t thriving or if you prefer more control over your tank's nutrient levels, you might want to consider using separate macro and micro fertilizers. Unlike all-in-one fertilizers, macro fertilizers supply the macronutrients your plants need in larger quantities. Micro fertilizers, on the other hand, contain just the trace micronutrients that are needed in smaller concentrations. Having two distinct formulas allows you to dose them separately at different times and frequencies.
For example, if you have a medium to high light planted tank with fast-growing plants, you may need to dose fertilizers every couple of days instead of just once a week to keep up with your plants’ higher nutrient demands. If you find that that nitrogen or other macronutrients are getting too high, then you can adjust your dosing schedule and cut back on the macro fertilizer without affecting your micronutrients. Separating your macro and micro dosing onto different days also helps prevent certain nutrients from reacting with each other in the water, which can make them harder for plants to absorb.
Why Your Plants Might Still Be Struggling
Even though all-in-one fertilizers promise the perfect formula for healthy growth, your aquarium plants might still look pale, stop growing, or develop holes in their leaves. That’s because everyone's water is different — your tap water might be soft without minerals, hard like liquid rock, or come with iron and other heavy metals. As hinted at previously, your fish and plant load can also affect how many nutrients are naturally available. If your plants are still struggling, it may be time to go beyond an all-in-one solution and figure out which specific nutrients they’re missing. In this section, we’ll show you how to spot signs of nutrient deficiencies, use test kits to identify limiting factors, and supplement individual nutrients to help your plants recover and thrive.
Primary Macronutrients: The Basic Building Blocks Plants Need
Primary macronutrients are the most essential elements that aquatic plants need in the greatest quantities. They directly enable major functions like new leaf and root growth, energy transfer, and overall plant development. Because they're used so heavily, these nutrients tend to run out the fastest and must be replenished regularly, especially in tanks with fast-growing plant species or low fish waste.
1) Nitrogen: The Key to Healthy, Green Plants
Nitrogen, often in the form of nitrate, is a vital nutrient for plants, since it plays a central role in chlorophyll production to give leaves their vibrant green color and supports the growth of larger, healthier plants. It’s naturally produced in your aquarium, but not having enough can severely stunt your plants’ growth.
- Source: Nitrogen comes from fish waste, decaying organic matter, and other decomposing materials.
- Problem: You may run out of nitrogen with fast-growing plants or if there’s a low fish-to-plant ratio where not enough waste is being produced.
- Symptoms: Older leaves at the bottom of the plant may turn yellow or brown (particularly at the tips), eventually becoming translucent and melting away.
- Solution: For a planted aquarium, aim for a nitrate level of 10–30 ppm, which you can measure with test kits or strips. This target range safely supports steady plant growth without harming fish or invertebrates. As mentioned before, dose a nitrogen-rich, all-in-one fertilizer or a nitrogen-specific supplement. For root feeders, use root tabs or a nutrient-rich substrate to supply nitrogen to the roots. Too much nitrogen can lead to algae problems and may be toxic to animals, so be sure to avoid excessive levels.
2) Phosphorus: The Root Growth Booster
Phosphorus is another essential macronutrient that helps aquatic plants grow larger and stronger. It contributes to energy transfer, root development, and the creation of DNA and RNA.
- Source: Phosphorus comes from the weathering of rocks and minerals, fish waste, and decaying organic material. Some fish foods like pellets and flakes contain more phosphorus than whole-ingredient foods like frozen or freeze-dried foods.
- Problem: While phosphate is usually supplied by fish waste and leftover food, it can become scarce in tanks with fast-growing plants, few fish, or diets low in phosphate.
- Symptoms: Older or larger leaves may appear darker or duller than usual, sometimes with a yellowish tinge along the edges. Over time, these leaves can turn translucent and melt away, and overall plant growth may become slow or stunted.
- Solution: Test your water for phosphate and aim for levels between 0.5–3 ppm. If phosphate is too consistently high, do more frequent water changes, switch to low-phosphorus foods, or add chemical filter media that absorbs excess phosphate. If phosphate is too low, consider using a phosphate supplement, removing any anti-phosphate filter media, or switching to fish foods with higher phosphorus content. Like nitrogen, excess phosphate can cause algae growth, so take care to avoid overdosing.
3) Potassium: The Ultimate Traffic Controller
Potassium does a lot of heavy lifting by assisting with water and nutrient movement, gas exchange, and enzyme activation. Plus, it boosts the absorption of nitrate and phosphate that helps with leaf growth and energy production. Low potassium can weaken plants, but it’s simple to spot and fix with a supplement.
- Source: Potassium also naturally comes from the weathering of rocks and minerals, so it’s not always present in high amounts in aquariums.
- Problem: Potassium deficiency typically affects fast-growing plant species and potassium-hungry plants like Java fern.
- Symptoms: Older leaves may develop tiny pinholes that enlarge into noticeable holes rimmed in yellow or brown. You may also see yellowing in older leaves and overall slower growth.
- Solution: Maintain potassium levels at 10–30 ppm, using a freshwater potassium test kit to monitor concentrations. Add a potassium supplement or a fertilizer formula that includes high potassium. Excess potassium usually doesn’t lead to algae issues, making it one of the more forgiving nutrients to adjust as needed.
Secondary Macronutrients: Essential Minerals for Healthy Growth
Secondary macronutrients are minerals that plants still need in relatively large amounts, but unlike the primary macronutrients, they aren’t directly involved in critical processes like plant metabolism, photosynthesis, or energy transfer that can have growth-limiting effects. Instead, they play more of a supportive role with tasks like structural integrity and nutrient transport. Depending on your tap water, you may already have enough minerals in your tank if you have hard water. However, if you have soft water or are using reverse osmosis (RO) water, you may need to “remineralize” the water by adding vital minerals back in to prevent plant development issues.
4) Calcium: The Backbone of Strong Growth
Calcium is responsible for building sturdy cell walls, aiding root growth, and improving disease resistance. While it's commonly found in hard water, soft water tanks often have reduced calcium levels, which can lead to plant growth problems.
- Source: Calcium comes from the weathering of rocks and soil and is commonly found in hard water with plenty of dissolved minerals like calcium.
- Problem: This issue is most commonly seen in soft water aquariums, where mineral levels are often too low.
- Symptoms: New leaves may grow in twisted or wrinkled shapes, and fresh shoots can eventually wither and die if the deficiency isn’t addressed. (The above photo shows a terrestrial wheat plant that also displays curled leaves from lack of calcium.)
- Solution: Aim for calcium levels between 10–40 ppm and GH (general hardness) of 4–8 dGH (70–140 ppm). You can test using a GH test (which measures both calcium and magnesium) or a calcium-specific test kit for freshwater tanks. To boost calcium levels, add GH supplements and remineralizers as needed after each water change, or use crushed coral in the substrate or filter media. Also, avoid using water treated by a water softener, since it removes calcium and magnesium while adding sodium.
5) Magnesium: The Photosynthesis Powerhouse
Magnesium sits at the center of the chlorophyll molecule — the green pigment that drives photosynthesis and helps plants produce energy. It works alongside calcium to maintain healthy growth, nutrient absorption, and enzyme activation. Like calcium, it’s naturally found in hard water but can be scarce in soft water tanks, leading to plants losing their green color due to a lack of chlorophyll.
- Source: Magnesium comes from the weathering of rocks and soil, as well as hard water that contains dissolved minerals like magnesium.
- Problem: Tanks with soft water or RO water often don’t have enough magnesium for healthy plant growth.
- Symptoms: Older leaves often turn pale or yellow, while leaf veins remain green and darker.
- Solution: Keep magnesium levels at 2–10 ppm and GH of 4–8 dGH (70–140 ppm), using a GH test kit or freshwater magnesium test kit to check your levels. Add GH supplements, remineralizers, or specialized fertilizer blends that contain magnesium. Avoid using water softened by a water softener, which strips out magnesium and calcium and replaces them with sodium.
Micronutrients: Trace Elements for Color and Strength
Micronutrients are needed in tiny amounts, but they play a big role in keeping your planted tank looking robust and vibrant. These include elements like iron, manganese, boron, and zinc. They support overall plant health and help your plants grow strong and colorful. Micronutrient deficiencies can be hard to spot, so using a separate micro fertilizer or adding individual supplements as needed can help fill in the gaps.
6) Iron: The Vibrant Color Enhancer
Iron helps aquarium plants get their rich green color by fueling chlorophyll production and assisting with energy transfer during photosynthesis. Contrary to popular belief, adding more iron won’t automatically make red plants redder. However, many red stem plants grow quickly — especially in high light tanks with CO2 gas — so it’s important to watch for signs of nutrient deficiencies such as iron.
- Source: Iron comes from natural weathering of rocks and minerals, iron-rich soils and clays, iron bacteria, and decomposing organic matter.
- Problem: Fast-growing plants can rapidly deplete iron to increase chlorophyll production and boost photosynthesis. Another issue is that iron dissipates quickly from the water as it oxidizes or binds with the substrate.
- Symptoms: New leaves or shoots at the top of the plant may look pale or yellow, while leaf veins stay green and darker. Unlike magnesium deficiency that affects older leaves, iron deficiency impacts newer growth, making it easier to distinguish between the two.
- Solution: Look for levels between 0.05–0.5 ppm by measuring with a freshwater iron test kit. If you find iron is lacking, then add an iron supplement, micro fertilizers containing iron, or iron-enriched root tabs. Also, make sure to remove chemical filtration like activated carbon, which can strip iron from the water. Avoid overdosing, since excess iron can encourage algae growth.
Getting your aquarium plants to thrive doesn't have to be complicated — but it does start with understanding what nutrients they need and how to spot the signs when something's missing. Whether you're just getting started or fine-tuning your setup, we’ve got a full lineup of aquarium fertilizers to help you find the right solution for your planted tank. Plus, we didn’t even get into the details of proper lighting and the usage of CO2 gas, so check out our related articles below and sign up for our newsletter for more plant care advice and expert tips.
Login and Registration Form